SNOWMOBILE
COMMUNITY APPLAUDS
WYOMING COURT DECISION
EAST LANSING, Mich., February 11, 2004
The American Council of Snowmobile Associations (ACSA) applauds the temporary
restraining order issued late Tuesday by Wyoming U.S. District Court Judge
Clarence Brimmer. Judge Brimmer's order directed the National Park Service
(NPS) to immediately quit "enforcing the 2001 Snowcoach rule" which
they had been directed to operate under by District of Columbia U.S. District
Court Judge Emmet Sullivan on December 16, 2003. Brimmer's order further
directed NPS to immediately "promulgate temporary rules for this 2004
snowmobile season that will be fair and equitable to snowmobile owners and
users, to the business community, and to the environmental interests."
"Judge Brimmer's ruling is encouraging because he defers to 'the experts',
NPS, to create a Winter Use Plan for the remainder of this season," stated
Christine Jourdain, ACSA Executive Director. In his decision, Brimmer went
as far as to state, "A single Eastern judge shouldn't have the unlimited
power to impose the old 2001 rule on the public and the business community, any
more than a single Western district judge should have the power to opt for a
different rule. Rather, these issues should be left in the care of the
NPS, the administrative agency into hands the public has entrusted this
matter."
In granting the temporary order, Brimmer further stated that "this Court
feels that ISMA and the State of Wyoming have a substantial likelihood of
success on the merits in their challenge of the validity of the 2000 Final EIS,
the 2000 ROD and the 2001 Snowcoach Rule." Jourdain added that,
"While this order only applies to the remainder of the current winter
season, the judge's perspective is particularly encouraging since the merits of
this lawsuit will be heard in his court over the coming months. It is
something we have always believed to have been improperly created and we look
forward to a fair hearing on that flawed process."
In response to Brimmer's order, the superintendents of Yellowstone and Grand
Teton National Parks have issued emergency rules, effective immediately, that
will be in effect for winter use management for the balance of the current
2003-2004 winter season that ends March 14, 2004. Under the new emergency
rules, all snowmobiles will continue to be required to be commercially guided.
No private, unguided entries will be allowed. Group size is restricted to
ten sleds plus the guide. Park hours will remain 7 AM - 9 PM daily.
The emergency rules allow a total of 780 snowmobiles per day to enter
Yellowstone National Park, an increase of 287 sleds per day over the 2001
Snowcoach Rule has that has been in effect under the December16th court order.
Under the new daily limits, the additional 287 guided sleds per day must be Best
Available Technology (BAT) sleds, while the initial allocation of 493 outfitter
sleds may be any type of snowmobile, including 2-strokes. The new daily
entrance limits by gate are as follows: West Entrance - 400 (122 must be
BAT), South Entrance - 220 (130 must be BAT), East Entrance - 100 (35 must be
BAT), North Entrance - 60 (0 must be BAT). Additionally, snowcoach-only
routes used the previous two seasons will remain in effect.
For Grand Teton National Park and the Rockefeller Parkway, a total of 50
snowmobiles per day will be allowed on the Continental Divide Snowmobile Trail
and on the Grassy Lake Road; however, no guides or BAT sleds are required.
Additionally, a total of 40 snowmobiles per day will be allowed access to
Jackson Lake solely for the purpose of fishing access and will require the
possession of a valid fishing license and fishing equipment.